An insurance adjuster says your back pain comes from an old injury rather than the recent crash. Does that mean you cannot recover compensation?
Not necessarily. Pre-existing injuries can complicate a claim, but they do not automatically eliminate it. Missouri law allows recovery for accident-related aggravation of an existing condition. The key is documenting what changed and connecting those changes to the collision.
Can You Recover Compensation for an Aggravated Injury?
Yes, when the evidence establishes that another person’s negligence worsened your condition. In Miller v. Gulf, Mobile & Ohio Railroad Company, the Missouri Supreme Court recognized that defendants generally are responsible for aggravation of pre-existing conditions caused by their negligence.
A defendant generally is not responsible for symptoms or deterioration that would have occurred independently of the crash. You may seek compensation for additional harm the collision caused, including aggravation of an existing condition.
For example, someone who previously managed occasional back discomfort might experience increased pain, additional treatment needs, and new work restrictions after a collision. Those changes deserve investigation, even if earlier records mention back problems.
What Should You Do When the Insurer Raises Your Medical History?
Ask for the Specific Reason
Ask the adjuster to explain the position in writing. Which condition is being identified? Which medical records or opinions support the conclusion? Is the insurer disputing the entire injury or only certain treatment expenses?
A general reference to arthritis or an earlier accident does not explain whether the current crash aggravated your condition.
Keep the insurer’s letters, emails, and requests. The car accident attorneys at Labovitz Law Firm can evaluate the stated reasons and help organize a response.
Give Your Providers an Accurate History
Tell your treating providers about previous injuries, symptoms, procedures, and relevant treatment. Explain what changed after the crash without exaggerating or minimizing your history. Useful details include:
- Where you previously experienced symptoms.
- How often those symptoms occurred.
- Whether you had stopped treatment before the collision.
- Activities you could perform before the crash.
- New symptoms, restrictions, or treatment needs afterward.
Concealing earlier problems can create inconsistencies that undermine your credibility. Accurate information helps providers evaluate the cause and extent of your car accident injuries.
Gather Records From Before and After the Crash
Earlier records can support your claim by showing your baseline condition. Post-crash records can help document a change. Relevant materials may include medical notes, imaging reports, therapy records, prescriptions, work restrictions, and bills.
A scan showing degeneration does not, by itself, answer every question about accident-related aggravation. Providers may need to consider your history, examination findings, symptoms, and the circumstances of the crash together.
What Evidence Helps Show That Your Condition Worsened?
A clear comparison between your condition before and after the collision is often useful.
| Before the Crash | After the Crash |
|---|---|
| Working without medical restrictions | Reduced hours or new restrictions |
| Occasional symptoms managed at home | More frequent symptoms requiring treatment |
| No ongoing therapy | A prescribed rehabilitation program |
| Performing ordinary household tasks | Documented difficulty completing those tasks |
These examples do not establish causation by themselves. Medical records and provider opinions can help connect the worsening to the crash, and medical testimony may be necessary when the condition or its cause is complex.
Missouri courts recognize that some straightforward injuries can be linked to an accident through ordinary observations. However, as Williams v. Jacobs explains, complicated injuries and serious questions about prior disability can require medical testimony.
Keep a factual symptom journal and records of missed work or assistance you need. Ask your provider whether the collision caused a new injury, aggravated an existing condition, or both.
Can an Insurer Argue That Some Losses Are Unrelated to the Crash?
Yes. However, the insurer’s position is not a final determination of your claim. Responsibility for causing a collision and responsibility for every claimed medical expense are separate questions.
In Lockhart v. United States, a federal appeals court applying Missouri law upheld a damages award that distinguished crash-related aggravation from an underlying degenerative condition. The outcome depended on the medical evidence in that case.
There is no automatic percentage reduction simply because you had a prior condition. The evidence must support which losses the collision caused or aggravated.
Should You Sign a Medical Authorization or Accept a Settlement?
Review medical authorizations carefully. Relevant earlier records may be necessary, but the scope and purpose of a request should be understood before you sign.
Ask an attorney about broad requests, recorded statements, and any cooperation duties under your own insurance policy. Do not assume you should refuse every request.
Likewise, avoid accepting a settlement before understanding your diagnosis, prognosis, and reasonably anticipated treatment. A release may resolve claims for future consequences as well as current losses.
Contact Labovitz Law Firm About Your St. Louis Injury Claim
An insurer’s statement that your injuries were pre-existing does not settle the issue. Your medical history and the effects of the crash need a careful review.
Labovitz Law Firm can help evaluate the insurer’s position, gather supporting records, and pursue compensation for accident-related harm.
If you were injured in a car accident in St. Louis, Missouri, contact Labovitz Law Firm to discuss your claim and legal options.


